I have a question for you about misdirected ACH payments. Our member’s (member #1) employer sent his paycheck to a wrong account because they mistook a #4 for a #9.
The member that mistakenly received the deposit (Member #2) thought this was manna from heaven and spent the funds. The likelihood of recovery from member #2 is small.
Is the credit union liable for this error because the routing and account numbers matched another open account?
This is a problem for member #1’s employer and the employer’s bank. NACHA rules permit RDFI’s to post ACH transactions based on account number alone. The RDFI can reject a transaction based on a name mismatch, but it isn’t required to do so. In this specific case, the liability rests solely with the ODFI for sending a transaction with an incorrect account number.
The ODFI may request recovery of the misdirected funds, but the RDFI doesn’t have to send anything back – even if there are funds to recover (but it’s a courtesy to so if you can).
The ODFI may have a legal claim against member #2 for unjust enrichment, but it’s not something the credit union needs to or should get involved with.
For more information, email Heather Line.
Your League-member benefits include the Compliance Hotline — providing exclusive access to dedicated compliance experts:
Using the above phone number and email address, you can gain access to a knowledgeable team that’s ready to address all your credit union’s compliance inquiries — promptly and efficiently. With the Compliance Hotline, you can proactively respond to impromptu questions and issues by getting clarity and insight on technical topics that normally slow you down. We want to help you unlock the full potential of your League membership by leveraging the resources and support you need to navigate the complex world of compliance effortlessly. We’re ALWAYS just a phone call or email away!
Additionally, other League-member compliance resources include:
Powered by ViClarity, a California’s Credit Unions and Nevada’s Credit Unions company.
